Eredar's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[StickDude Killing Arena 4]

a bit one-sided

the animation was pretty good, but it seemed to be that only one stickman would lead, kill, have to reload or something and eventually die. try adding more of an "arena" element where many people would be fighting at the same time. not just one guy with a grenade launcher/bow/uzi/ect killing several poorly armed sticks before being destroyed to make room for the next guy.

also, it strikes me as quite odd that you could build a helicopter and a jetpack in full 3d using Swift 3D, but you still constructed the background in 2D.. im sure making a 3d background would have made for an interesting style and some improvement.

the concept of a stickfighting arena is, unfortunatley, very unoriginal, and it has become the practice of many to put such animations with just simple sticks blowing each other up with the same motions time and time again. i suggest that, with your skill, (and i think you've definetly got talent) you go and put some real time and effort into an orignal concept, which will help you stand out more.

[Join The Army!]

great to see it progress

great movie, you've definetly got some talent when it comes to animating, but its been awesome to see this get a front page after first coming across it on the BBS.

i hope to see more from you in future, you've got a good style, and i hope it does wonders for you at university :)

[Knee Deep in Death]

nice.

pretty damn good. so you didnt rotoscope it at all? looks like you did, though

[Waterlollies]

....speechless.

adam philips does it again! beautiful!

[eBaums world dot com]

fuck you ebaum.

ebaum does not seserve to live.

( great flash :D )

[Charlie The Unicombat]

pretty good

i think you handled the animation side of it pretty well considering all you had were some static unicorn models. :)

[Spooky Scary Skeletons]

im loving this!

that was amazing. animation was pretty good! love the song too, though.
i suspect the part with the piano keys was done in 3d. was it?

[Warhammer Endless War]

animation= good. graphics= below aveage

no doubt, the animation was quite good, in fact the way the characters moved and shot (and got shot) was quite impressive but the actual graphics were below average.. you need to work on them.

[Munch's War]

brilliant!

i loved it! it was well thought out, the lines were good great ideas mate!

munch: what are you doing?
adam: drooling ALL over the video....... sorry about that

you're great man, just great.

munchmed responds:

thankyou :)

[Evolution of the Unicorn]

very nice. very nice indeed.

beautiful animation!

good music choice too.